[Author’s Note: This post is part of the 7 part series Conspiracy Check. The series factchecks
the claims of Liberal commentator Thom Hartmann concerning allegations of fraud
and treason during 5 presidential elections.]
Hartmann’s next conspiracy concerned the 1980 election.
Hartmann alleged that Regan made a deal with the Iranians that they would not
release the American hostages in Iran until after the election. In exchange for
this Reagan allegedly agreed to give the Iranians weapons. The hostage crisis
was a major blow to Carter’s reelection campaign.
There is quite a bit of evidence for this conspiracy.
Journalist Robert Parry and his colleges at consortiumnews.com have also described
the evidence for the October Surprise conspiracy in multiple articles. Israeli
intelligence agent Ari Ben-Menashe supports the
claim. A Russian
intelligence report reached the same conclusion. Former Iranian president
Bani-Sadr supported the allegation in a letter to the US
Congress. David Andelman, the biographer of French intelligence chief Alexandre
deMarenches, testified
that de Marenches had told him that the Regan reelection campaign met with
Iranians in Paris. Jamshid
Hashemi, an Iranian arms trader, says that he arranged meetings between the
Iranians and the Regan reelection campaign. Hashemi also alleges
that George H.W. Bush met with Iranian representatives in Paris, a charge Bush
has repeatedly denied.
Newsweek, the New Republic, and Congress all launched
investigations into the October Surprise conspiracy theory and concluded that
it didn’t occur. However, each relied on creating an alibi
for William Casey such that he could not have attended a meeting in Madrid as Jamshid
Hashemi had described. Robert Parry was able to discredit those alibis and in
2011 he found a memo
from the George H.W. Bush Library that said that “a cable from the Madrid
embassy indicated that Bill Casey was in town, for purposes unknown.”
So is the conspiracy true? Possibly, but I am going to hold
off my conclusion until more classified documents from the George H.W. Bush Library
that the library describes as relating
to the allegation are declassified. However, there is enough evidence that I do
not fault Hartmann for believing it is true.
No comments:
Post a Comment