Javed Iqbal
was a Staten Island businessman
who sold satellite television services. One of the television stations he
offered his customers was Al Manar. Al Manar is the Arabic-language television
channel of Hezbollah, a militant organization that is considered a terrorist
organization by the US government. For offering Al Manar to his customers,
Javed Iqbal was sentenced
in April 2009 to 5 years and 9 months in prison. The sentence resulted from a
plea deal in December 2008 where Javed Iqbal pled guilty to one count of
providing material support to a terrorist organization. Javed’s lawyer says
that Javed also offered his customers access to Christian broadcasting and
adult entertainment (porn) channels, hardly what you would expect of a Muslim
extremist.
A federal
prosecutor in the case said
that Hezbollah used the channel to recruit members and suicide bombers and
raise money for weapons and operations. Al Manar has also been accused of inciting
violence. If these claims are true, and I believe they are, then the US
government has a legitimate reason to ban Al Manar. However, I don’t speak
Arabic myself, so I cannot be completely sure.
Nonetheless, a satellite service
provider should not be punished with jail time, let alone over 5 years, for offering
the TV channel to his customers. The government should have asked Javed Iqbal
to stop offering the channel and if he refused, he should have been fined. If
he was still defiant, the government could have revoked his business license.
But to take away 5 years of someone’s life for providing his customers access
to Al Manar, a channel they wanted to watch, is inexcusable.
POSTSCRIPT:
Decide for yourself if you think Al Manar should be banned. Here is an editorial
arguing in
favor of banning Al Manar. Here is an editorial arguing against
banning Al Manar. NPR
did a story on this case with a member of the ACLU and a person supporting the
banning of Al Manar. Wikipedia
has a entry on the TV channel. Here is a link to the English-language
hompage of Al Manar News. The Arabic-language TV channel is available online.
No comments:
Post a Comment